Not Being An Amazon Helps Etsy

In every local market, there’s always that one stall you remember.

The one with handmade candles. Or clay earrings. Or bookmarks painted with care.

They do not come from factories but from kitchens, bedrooms, and garages by real people. Now, imagine all those creators in one giant digital market.

That’s Etsy.

It started as a simple site in 2005, built by a woodworker who wanted to sell furniture online. But it became something much bigger.

Today, Etsy is home to over 7 million sellers.

And it is worth more than $15 billion.

The Big Idea:

The Secret Behind Etsy

Most online marketplaces want to scale fast. They chase growth, add more categories, and try to serve everyone. Etsy did the opposite.

Instead of trying to be the next Amazon, it became a home for handmade. While other sites sold electronics, fast fashion, and factory-made goods, Etsy focused on:

• Handmade products

• Vintage items

• Craft Supplies

That made it unique from day one.

It wasn’t trying to be the cheapest but was trying to offer same-day shipping.

It just wanted to help small creators find buyers who cared.

That single focus shaped everything:

• The kind of sellers it attracted

• The design of its product pages

• The way it grew traffic (without ads!)

• The community it built

Etsy didn’t try to win by competing with big players.

It won by choosing a different game. That choice to go niche, stay human, and think long-term turned a side project into a billion-dollar ecosystem.

Behind the Magic:

Etsy’s Growth Strategies

We saw what Etsy did differently.

Now, let’s see how they built this $15B empire, step by step.

1. Etsy owned a tiny corner of the internet

Instead of selling everything, Etsy sold one thing: uniqueness.

You couldn’t find Apple products there - no mass-produced jeans.

Just hand-knitted baby socks, wooden toys, and vintage typewriters.

That made Etsy stand out.

While others competed for speed, Etsy competed on story, soul, and craft.

For example, they said this on their About Us page:

That made their platform easier to design, market, and grow.

By focusing only on handmade goods, Etsy built a place where artists and crafters felt seen. That emotional connection created a sticky experience.

Then, when you bought from Etsy, the entire journey felt personal.

2. Etsy made every product page an SEO goldmine

Etsy didn’t throw money at Facebook ads.

Instead, they played the long game... SEO.

Each time a seller added a product, Etsy:

• Used the product title in the URL

• Let sellers write detailed descriptions

• Tagged the product with smart categories

That made thousands of pages Google-friendly.

And Etsy had to put no effort into any of this.

Think about it: Etsy would pop up if someone searched for a handmade ceramic coffee mug because a seller had listed that item.

For example, Etsy showed up in the 2nd position in the organic results when I searched for handmade bookmarks. Imagine the same for other keywords.

Etsy turned its user-generated content into free marketing.

That is how they grew long-tail traffic without constantly publishing blog posts or running new ad campaigns.

3. Etsy made sellers feel like co-founders

Most platforms treat their users like inventory.

Etsy did the opposite. They treated creators like partners.

Each Etsy shop had its page, logo, and story. Sellers could customize their stores, talk to buyers directly, and track real-time data. For example:

There were forums. Monthly newsletters. Guides to grow.

Even shoutouts from Etsy’s editorial team.

That freedom made sellers feel in control and valued. And because Etsy helped sellers grow, sellers became brand ambassadors. They stayed longer.

They told friends. Etsy became the default place for creators to start.

4. Etsy stayed flexible but never lost its soul

Even as Etsy scaled, it didn’t forget why it started. Sure, they introduced shipping integration and personalization and even went public.

But through all that, they stayed true to their mission:
Help small creators succeed.

This focus helped Etsy avoid the growth-at-all-costs trap. They didn’t chase trends. They made updates that helped creators first, not just shareholders.

During the pandemic, when supply chains broke down, and creators struggled, Etsy ran ads asking people to support small shops. (Read all indetail here)

That alignment between brand and behavior is what builds long-term trust.

In short, Etsy’s growth wasn’t magic. It was:

• Niche + SEO + Trust

• Combined with patience, care, and clear values

Where It Fits:

Ready-to-Use Marketing Strategy

PHASE 1:
Claim Your Niche

• Objective: Stand out by being specific, not big.

1. Define your one-sentence niche

Instead of saying: We help small businesses grow.

Say: We help Etsy jewelry sellers turn browsers into buyers.

Keep it ultra-clear:

• WHO you help

• WHAT you help them do

• WHY you are different

2. Create a Niche Welcome Kit

It is a lightweight marketing starter pack:

• A simple landing page for that audience

• 3 content pieces that solve niche-specific problems

• One freebie (template, checklist, etc.) to collect emails

Tools to use: Carrd / Notion + Beehiiv + ConvertKit

PHASE 2:
Make SEO Your Salesperson

• Objective: Build a long-term, low-cost marketing engine.

1. Turn every user action into content

Let your users generate searchable content, like product listings, reviews or testimonials, user-submitted FAQs, and success stories.

Then, structure it for Google:

• Use keyword-rich URLs (like Etsy did)

• Add meta titles/descriptions automatically

• Let users tag content with relevant keywords

2. Publish Niche SEO Stacks

Find 5–10 high-intent keywords your users are already searching.

Examples for Etsy-like brands include:

• Best handmade jewelry shops in [city]

• Unique birthday gifts for dog lovers

• How to price handmade items for Etsy

Write helpful, honest answers. Link to your platform naturally.

Tools to use: Lowfruits.io (keyword ideas) + ChatGPT (drafts) + Webflow (landing pages)

PHASE 3:
Empower Your Creators

• Objective: Turn users into your marketing team.

1. Give sellers their brand tools

Just like Etsy:

• Custom shop pages (with their URLs)

• Upload logo and banner

• Write their story and description

• Easy share buttons for Twitter, IG, Pinterest

This builds community and drives traffic to your site through their promotion.

2. Create a Partner Playbook

Give your early sellers or creators a launch kit:

• Email templates to announce their shop

• Sample tweets or IG captions

• A monthly content calendar

• Reward them with exposure (feature them in newsletters, and socials)

This kind of love creates loyalty.

Resources For You

Templates: Struggling to create high-converting DTC ads? Get 60+ proven DTC ad templates used by top brands. Plug, tweak, and launch winning ads instantly.

Hunting Marketing Jobs: Check out GrowthRoles. It's a job board just for marketers. From email marketing to social media marketing, find your dream role today.

Blog:

• The ultimate guide to SEO for e-commerce websites

• How to stand out in an over-saturated market

• User-generated content (UGC) examples + how to use it

YT Video: How to rank no. 1 on Google: Ecommerce SEO secrets

That's all for today, marketers! Got feedback? 
Help us write what you need by answering the poll below and commenting.

Any requests for the next breakdown? 
Let me know by replying to this email!